Kihei & Kauai in March

Changed my mind about staying in Maui for 8 days, now want to spend 1/2 in Kauai. I%26#39;m going the 1st week in March. Should I go to Kauai 1st then Kihei or vice versa? It looks like Kauai is just as nice as Maui %26amp; the accomodations are about the same. Where should I stay in Kauai? I just want to relax %26amp; go to the beach. I don%26#39;t need fancy, just clean and quiet, and not many kids. Probably won%26#39;t be eating in so a full kitchen is not necessary. Thanks!!

Kihei %26amp; Kauai in March

we love the Poipu area on Kauai. It%26#39;s on the dryer side of the island and it%26#39;s a lovely area. Poipu Beach is outstanding. There are many condos to pick from there. We have stayed at Poipu Shores and Poipu Kapili, there are many other choices that are less expensive. I also would recommend Kiahuna Plantation. The property fronts Poipu Beach. Try VRBO for rentals.

Kihei %26amp; Kauai in March

So you are going to fly from one island to the other for 4 days. The time getting to the islands and home are about 2 days and getting from one island to the other is at least 1/2 day. I would do one island for the entire time.

shanty has a very good point. island hopping takes a great deal of time and literally eats a whole day by the time you pack, check out, turn in your car, sit at the airport (when you could be on the beach) then wait for your luggage again, rent another car, check into another hotel or condo...etc..

You may just want to stay in one place.

It all makes sense, I was thinking the same thing, except that getting from SLC to Lihue in 1 day is difficult, I have to fly ATA to get the points. I%26#39;ll have to re-arrange my flight %26amp; leave from a city that gets me to Honolulu in time to catch a flight to Kauai. Thanks, I just can%26#39;t wait to get to Hawaii, I%26#39;m counting the days....

We just returned from a trip where we spent one week in Maui and then one week in Kauai. We took the only direct flight with Aloha Airlines. It was at about 2 PM. All other flights you have to fly to Honolulu and ten kauai.

Experience with Royal Lahaina or Kaapalani Beach Hotel?

Just wondering if anyone has experience staying at the Royal Lahaina Resort or Kaapalani Beach Hotel. Is it honeymoon worthy? I need to keep the cost down, but am looking for a nice place for us to honeymoon rather than a family place. Looking for something at least 3 Star worthy.

Any input would be greatly appreciated!!

Experience with Royal Lahaina or Kaapalani Beach Hotel?

I asked the same question over a forum.

We have decided on Kaanapali Beach hotel, which won most people%26#39;s vote.

They were similar, but KB.Hotel was better value, great looking pool... and so far excellent customer service.

We%26#39;re going to stay there for 5 nights in June.

I think it should be honeymoon worthy. I%26#39;d definitely consider it if it was for my honeymoon.

Its also 3 - 4 star too.. can%26#39;t remember which.

Experience with Royal Lahaina or Kaapalani Beach Hotel?

Aloha - my husband %26amp; I went to Maui last May and seriously considered Royal Lahaina, but for us it just didn%26#39;t feel right. So I dug more and discovered Kaanapali Beach Hotel - now I consider them Ohana (family).

It%26#39;s not posh at all, but very relaxed and so comfortable. Highly convenient to Black Rock and great snorkeling, Lahaina, Whalers Village is a quick and easy walk, etc.

The staff there were incredibly nice, every single person there was gracious and welcoming - even the ones who were obviously having a %26#39;bad%26#39; day were friendly.

I did post a review - but frankly I can do better.

The grounds are lovely and open - nice pool, lots of chairs to lounge in and views that are still on my PC screen! We loved the nightly shows, even though we only %26#39;watched%26#39; two we enjoyed them nightly from our balcony. If you want to be left alone, its easy there. If you want to get acquainted with other guests it%26#39;s easy. If you are into nightlife the bar is open and laughter to be found, as well as the show.

Will we go back? Absolutely - until we stayed there I did not consider myself a Kaanapali type of person.

We saw weddings daily! We were there for our anniversary and yes, it is conducive to romance. It is also good for families.

When are you going?

\

I will say that you should consider/request the Maui or Lanai wings thoug, they have been renovated and are much nicer. Views are good from any floor. Molokai and Kauai wings are still not done over and leave a bit to be disired.

Rooms are clean, the grounds are meticulously cared for, and we truly hated to have to leave.

I forgot to add - while staying there we walked past the Sheraton and north over to Royal Lahaina, we walked all the way up to the new villas - it%26#39;s not nearly as convenient and sits back from the beach. The cottages at RL sit closer to the beach but appear dark. Not as private as you might think since the walkway runs through the cottages.

At KBH unless you are totally against breakfast, it%26#39;s a good value and we rarely ate lunch - if we did then our dinner was very small.

At KBH Some people thing it%26#39;s a bit of a time warp there, but frankly we thought it far more Hawaii and the Island of Maui thinks so too. It is repeatedly voted ';the most Hawaiian hotel'; for a reason. It%26#39;s very relaxing/

Best Luau on Maui???

Looking for opinions on which luau is the best.

If you have been recently...let me know your opinion...where to go...or more importantly...where not to go.

Thanks!

Best Luau on Maui???

I had the same question at one time..

Maybe this search will help you.

http://www.tripadvisor.com/SearchForums?ff=86%26amp;geo=29220%26amp;scope=2%26amp;q=best+luau%26amp;returnTo=%2FShowForum-g29220-i86-Maui_Hawaii.html

Best Luau on Maui???

We attended the Old Lahaina Luau about a year ago- really enjoyed it. It was very classy and well put together. We were able to see the Sheraton luau from our lanai, and it seemed much more cheesy and corny (Aloooooooooooooooo-ha!!) I think it depends on what you want, but the OLL really is a professional group.

Aloha!

Old Lahaina Luau

Feast at Lele

I think these 2 are the best.

If you want a more intimate setting, try the feast at Lele, but BOTH are VERY good.

Bryan Brown

BBrown9825@aol.com

Drums of the Pacific at the Hyatt has the best fire knife dancer on Maui.

Feast at Lele is excellent.

Old Lahaina Luau is decent but no fire knife dancer.

Royal Lahaina Luau is OK. Perhaps the best budget luau as there are many coupons %26amp; a kids menu in addition to a traditional luau menu. Don%26#39;t go to this one if you are not taking kids as they can be distracting.

We prefer the Old Lahaina Luau... beautiful grounds, staff all seem to enjoy working there and the food is better than most (IMO). The OLL show concentrates on that which is Hawaiian... and no tourists dragged up on the stage to wear grass skirts and coconut bras. They sell out nightly, so make reservations early (seats are first come, first assigned).

Are there ';better'; seats that I should ask for when I make my reservation?

We just went to Old Lahaina Luau last week and it was terrific. So well organized, great food, terrific staff, greeted with lei%26#39;s and mai tai%26#39;s at the door...can%26#39;t go wrong. We sat at a table...if you think your legs can handle it...you can sit at the more traditional mat style tables which are situated right around the stage. Pretty decent seating for the show no matter where you are though!

Enjoy

Unless you%26#39;re very flexible and have a good back I wouldn%26#39;t recommend the floor seating. Remember, you%26#39;ll be sitting there for a couple of hours. The tables are back a bit but are raised and have good views. The earlier you book, the better seats you can get.

When we were in Maui in %26#39;04, we went to luau in Wailea %26amp; OLL. BOTH were good but OLL defintely better.

Went to Feast at LeLe this past Thurs.

In my opinion, food was by far best at Feast at LeLe. Enjoyed ALL shows but OLL was best.

We loved the Feast at Lele. We booked about 4 weeks in advance and got front row seating. Food and service was great!

get ride of

Stay in Hana for 20+

I was wondering if any one has any suggestions. We have a group of 20+ and we will be in Maui for 8 days, we%26#39;re getting ready to book our stay for 7 of the days in Kaanapali. Soo... that leaves 1 day to find a place for 20 people. Everything I read says to stay in Hana for a day if possible..but I haven%26#39;t been able to find accomodations for all of us. Any suggestions? We%26#39;ve never been to Maui before.

Thank you

Stay in Hana for 20+

You don%26#39;t *have* to overnight in Hana. Most people make it a daytrip. (Did you try Hotel Hana?) Or, are you saying you have only seven nights booked on Maui and need to book an eighth night *somewhere*?

Stay in Hana for 20+

try calling the Hana Kai condos. They may be able to help if you book it far enough in advance. The hotel Hana Maui may help too but the rooms are pretty pricey, but you may get a group discount. You may also be able to book a few vaction rentals. Go to Hanamaui.com and click on accomadations. Good luck and aloha.......... otto

First Time in Wowee Maui - Luau & Restaurant Review

Just back from Maui and had all these wonderful plans to eat in ALLLL these great places but in the end, you end up wanting to do so much, you work in what you can WHEN you can, WHERE you are

I was determined to eat at Ferraros and Humumus... That was my biggest disappointment BUT... could not be helped so made the most of it (who can pout in Beautiful Hawaii??)

Ferraros (wouldn%26#39;t you know) at the Luxurious 4 Seasons---

was undergoing some construction issues and not open for

lunch. (Time-wise, lunch was the only time we could go on our

last day...) so, .............

We went to the Bistro at the 4 Seasons which had amazing

views (better than Ferraros) higher up and very open.. It was

casual but so balmy and relaxing... An economy trick... One

person gets an appetizer and the other gets an entree and share

a dessert... Works well, cheaper and you get more to taste..

The Banana-Chocolate Bread Pudding with Rum and Whipping

Cream was finger-lickin%26#39; (Did you know I was from KY?)

The tale on Humuhumas was that it also was not open when we

were at the Grand Wailea... It was beautiful!!.. Tho the GW was absolutely breathtaking...so large (grand?). . like a marble palace... eye-popping, so lovely and not crowded felt so spacious and tranquil, beautiful blue fountain steps, exotic statues, artwork, stately, soaring up as far as you could see.. (certainly not like anything ever seen in KY).. Okay, okay, getting carried away again...

Back to the Restaurants...

Charleys in Paia does fantastic breakfasts. The servers are all really friendly and helpful. We had lunch there and it was just ';OK';

(not really that good)..and (sorry Charley fans!!) but, it was not that clean.. Probably if you did not go all the way back to the restrooms, you would not know, but trust me, it was VERY unclean.. bathrooms some of the worst I have been in (Hubby echoed this in men%26#39;s bathroom)Towards the bathroom...carpet, walls and doors very dirty, even smelled in the back hallway... Very rundown and unkept... Sorry, but I promised to always be honest.. I would want to know this. They seem like really nice people but cleanliness is a biggie in a restaurant...

Mamas Fish House--

Already did a review on this..It was the BEST... Best location, Best service, Best food, Best decor, Best view, etc. etc... More details on my earlier post (check after May 12).. Even tho I do not like fish, Hubby%26#39;s fish was amazing... So glad we went there!! Make reservations. No sunset view..Daytime is a great beach view...

Hana Hotel--

We loved it. Very tranquil, island feel, relaxing, great food and service. We went at lunch and truly enjoyed it. Lovely setting, nice to walk around and enjoy the resort and view. $$ but worth it!! Great way to unwind after such a long Road to Hana trip...

Marcos Grill and Deli Ate a quick dinner there our first night in. Service was great and our Chicken dish was good. Not great, but good... Nice people... No view. On a busy street...

K ikis Terrace at the Sheraton Maui (our hotel)

We loved it. We read that their breakfast buffet was not that good.. Well, they must have done a makeover because it could not have been better.. Sitting at the huge and lovely Koi Pond, eating a 5* breakfast was a real tranquil and lovely Maui moment... Buffet was pricey ($23?) but something you should do at least once, in my humble opinion. Plus it frees you up for the rest of the day..

Then a nice brisk walk around the lovely grounds to ';walk it off'; is a plus! Such a great location on Kaanapali Beach... End it by going up to the 8th floor for the most breathtaking scenic view of the entire beach... (and mountains...)

Manele Bay Clubhouse (near the 4 Seasons) on Lanai--

Wow! What an unforgettable amazing panoramic view of the Island of Lanai and the gorgeous sparkling ocean.... The Clubhouse Cafe (lunch) at the golfcourse is perched on a hill and has the BEST view, great service and really good food... Another Maui Moment!

We did this following our Challenge at Manele Bay golf experience which was a long-awaited wish for hubby and fun for me too!

Hula Grill in the Whalers Village at Kaanapali

This was a highly regarded restaurant in my research reviews and I see why now. It is right on the walk to the Whaler%26#39;s Village (right there at it).. and a relaxing, casual outdoor area with beach chairs and a sandy area for your toes... Food and service is really great. One of the best chicken sandwiches I have ever eaten.. Lots of unusual toppings to make it taste very tropical and delicious. One sandwich was plenty for two! The couple beside me split a sandwich so they could eat a dessert.. It was a winner!!

Leilanis on the Beach at the Whalers Village on Kaanapali-

I had been wondering where this place was and wanted to eat there and found it when we ate at Hula Grill. They are right across the sidewalk from each other at the Whaler%26#39;s Village. It also is very casual with beach chairs and serves a great breakfast (per some fellow diners)..Our sandwiches were fine but have to admit Hula Grill has them beat!! Servers are all friendly and atmosphere very laid back and beachy.... BOTH OF THESE OUTDOOR RESTAURANTS ARE ALONG THE SIDEWALK WITH THE OCEAN IN FRONT AND WHALER%26#39;S VILLAGE BEHIND...

---LUAU---

FEAST AT LELE-- We researched and studied a lot about this one but did not want to sit on the ground and go thru lines to eat so opted for this more upscale (or so they say..) Luau.. It is on the beach by Pacifico and next to ';Io '; Restaurants (sister dining spots).. in Lahaina... Pricey $110 each but it was a more enjoyable %26amp; relaxed setting, no going thru lines, great servers and we had a table for two in the very front..(due to early reservations..) I do not want to offend the locals and their cuisine, and it may be due to our lack of sophistication but we did not like any of the food.. We know it was well prepared and were told it was the ';best of the best'; of all luaus.. see Io and Pacifico (same chefs).. BUT, We were given approximately 6-7different courses with 2-4 various foods at each course and they explained what they were, and we tried to eat them (and really wanted to) but just could not.. Guess our southern style cooking is just too far from this healthier cuisine.. But, we loved the Luau, the entertainment was top notch and was done in stages so there was no empty time waiting.. It was all very beautiful and artistic and so lovely with the lighting on the beach .. the beautiful water sparking in the background a premier event..I think most people would like the food, we are just a little particular in our tastes, I think. A lot of different cuisines in one Luau---

??Reef at the Sheraton-- Their food was REALLY good .We did a couple of take outs from here for convenience in the evening because we got back so late and I did not want to get ';dinner ready'; to go out again... Food quality and taste was excellent.!!

Sonz at the Hyatt-- (Formally Swan Court).... The most romantic place at the Beach-- We checked them all out--- LOVELY.....

We searched to find the most beautiful and unique place for our special anniversary dinner at the beach... It is stunning...so very beautiful at night..The lighting is sooo romantic and lovely... restaurant opens out into a beautifully lit waterfall in a sparkling lagoon which is beyond words.. beautiful at night.. Lovely in daytime also...

We could not have had a lovelier table or more romantic setting but, it was an extremely busy night and they were short-staffed and had some parties... and, yes, it was NOT smooth sailing... shame, because it was so special The service was very very very slow.... So, I cannot rate it because they said it was an unusual night BUT, the food was really amazing...steak, steamed vegetables and amazing parmesan twice-baked potatoes....Wish I could give it a thumbs up but only can do that for the setting and quality of food!! At least go by and see it or try a breakfast or lunch there....

Aloha Mixed Plate--

I have dreaded sharing this beause I know how many people like it... We each had a mixed plate (two different kinds) and just could not eat it... It ALL had a greasy taste and it just was NOT good. We loved the casual, laid back, on the beach setting and I hope others like it but we did not. Maybe we are just too particular. I have to share our experience though and be honest. I am sure others will like it, according to the reviews...

LAST AMAZING ALOHA EATING EXPERIENCE---

On our last day, we bought the succulent, delicious pastries at the Westin (Continental Breakfast) in the indoor/outdoor waterfall area. They have cereals, fruit, pastries, gourmet coffee and juices with a microwave for warming.... Anyway, it was one of the nicest ';Farewell Hawaii'; moments sitting beside the pink flamingos, the enchanting waterfalls, black swans and lovely foliage as we shared our thoughts on the last day... They also have a $25 breakfast buffet BUT the seating is not as tranquil, private and beautiful so opted for the continental near the waterfall... A wonderful end to our amazing Maui experience...

You must go into the Westin for an enchanting tropical Maui moment! The Hyatt is also a must for a similar experience!!

I sincerely hope all of this helps shed a little light on some of the Maui and Lanai restaurants. We did not do near as much as we planned but that is a lesson too... You have to ';go with the flow'; and not get too bogged down with checklists...';Feel the Island breezes and slow down...';

Please remember this is only our experience and not meant to be critical in any way... Peaceful Aloha to all...

First Time in Wowee Maui - Luau %26amp; Restaurant Review

Wow! Thanks for the great reviews. I appreciate your honesty. I have a question about Mama%26#39;s Fishhouse. I know it probably sounds weird, but my husband and I are are not big fish eaters...but from everything that I have heard I still consider this a ';must do';. Can you tell me if they also offer steak on their menu? I checked their menus online and only saw fish.

First Time in Wowee Maui - Luau %26amp; Restaurant Review

In answer to your question....

I also do not like fish but knew we HAD to go... I ordered duck and it was mahvelous-- I had to taste my honey%26#39;s fish and I could not believe how much I loved it. I was told if you do not like fish, ';Wait till you go to Hawaii';, they have so much, so unique and so wonderfully prepared, you will love something!. They were right.

We could not believe how much I loved it. It is not your basic mainland fish.. but much better tasting and more qourmet there...

The servers at Mamas were sooo accommodating since there are some things I cannot eat (or do not like) and they worked with me and adjusted the entree to suit me. I was surprised and did not expect it at all... A glorious experience... Maybe we just got a nice and helpful server? He (and another) went out of his way to please... The best meal of our trip!!!

Feel free to call them (not that expensive) and ask any questions...

Have a great trip.... Aloha

Thank you Buni for your detailed report. It has helped me decide on a couple of places. Hula Grill sounds like a must do. Did the construction at Ferraro%26#39;s look like a long term project? We are going in a couple of weeks. Did you notice-does the Bistro only serve lunch? I am considering a day trip to Lanai-do you need reservations at the Manele Bay Clubhouse? Our family does the split appetizer and entree thing too.

Thank you Buni for your detailed report. It has helped me decide on a couple of places. Hula Grill sounds like a must do. Did the construction at Ferraro%26#39;s look like a long term project? We are going in a couple of weeks. Did you notice-does the Bistro only serve lunch? I am considering a day trip to Lanai-do you need reservations at the Manele Bay Clubhouse? Our family does the split appetizer and entree thing too.

Dreamin and First time Maui-

Wow! I also had some type of fowl (duck?) entree because I don%26#39;t normally like fish either but tasted my hubby%26#39;s fish and really did like his. It all looked great. I think his fish was Ahi but not sure. I think a lot of people who do not like fish go there and find something to eat. We found the servers to be eager to help and explained items on the menu. There were other people we noticed who did not get fish tho it was difficult to tell what exactly they got. I did see some shrimp, I believe. It was a wonderful dining experience...

When were you there, Dreamin? We just got back.

First Time Maui--You should go. I am sure you will find something. Beautiful setting! A real Hawaiian experience! Enjoy!!

Flamom-

The Bistro is so casual that I am sure it is probably only for lunch tho I am not positive. Ferraros did not seem like it would be a long term construction. Just a small thing. Bet it will be over in 2 weeks or sooner. Lucky you! I hope you enjoy it! It was my big favorite of all that I researched.

The Manele Bay Clubhouse was not crowded (also casual) for lunch the day we went. What a lovely view! No, no reservations needed but yes, definitely for the golf course... If you have kids, they will LOVE the ferry ride, especially going back (if the waves are high) wow!! what a ride!! I could not stop giggling (once I knew we were not going to turn over) Aloha

Thank you Buni. I have a 13 and 14 year old. I am looking into the Jeep rental expedition on Lanai with the ferry ride. It sounds like fun.

Dreamin %26amp; Bunibleu -

Thanks. I will definitely keep this on my ';must do'; list. Thanks for making it an easier decision. I am so happy to have finally discovered trip advisor. I know that our trip will be so much better because of everyones honest feedback.

Aloha Bunibleu ~ Sounds like you enjoyed your trip very much and you made the best of everything. What a great detailed report, and I you certainly have your opinion on the restaurants that you didn%26#39;t really care for, that%26#39;s why we are all here, we can%26#39;t all have the same experience.

As far as Charley%26#39;s goes.... I understand what you are saying. It%26#39;s not the best place in town to eat, it%26#39;s more of a bar type atmosphere, but Charley%26#39;s fits right in with the atmosphere of the town. As I worked right up the street, we would stop in to play pool and happy hour, and hoping for a glimpse of Willie Nelson, and for years I never even knew Charley was named after a dog.

Luau in Kauai

So, can anyone tell me who really does have the best luau on Kauai?

Luau in Kauai

I have read lots of posts who say Smith%26#39;s Luau is the best. http://www.smithskauai.com./

Luau in Kauai

I agree that SMITH%26#39;S is good..

Another vote for Smith%26#39;s.

Everything I have seen about Smith%26#39;s makes me think it is touristy? Is that the case? But, I guess all Luau%26#39;s are touristy, right?

What do you think about the Luau at The Princeville Resort?

Everything I have seen about Smith%26#39;s makes me think it is touristy? Is that the case? But, I guess all Luau%26#39;s are touristy, right?

My thought exactly. I had a luau booked, until yesterday. My wife and I decided to forgo the luau and instead take the kids to a real nice dinner like Tidepools.

We got back yesterday from two weeks on the north shore; our 14th trip to Kauai in the last 10 years (restaurant report to come in a few days). This year, we went to our first luau, at Smith%26#39;s -- and we had a blast. They were very efficient in moving the crowd through the grounds and the buffet line, and the show was enjoyable. The drinks were free-flowing (they even served good Scotch -- J%26amp;B). Yes, it was touristy, but I can%26#39;t imagine a commercial luau that isn%26#39;t. Plus, the fact that this is a family-run Kauai business seemed to make things friendly.

wyrman - we were on the verge of booking a luau too - but decided against it due to the touristy-factor. At this point in my life, I%26#39;ve ';been there, done that'; with those touristy things (did a luau in Disney World - good show but it felt like I was at a big Bat/Bar Mitzvah or wedding)... so many other wonderful things to see and do on Kauai that are more appealing to us... different strokes for different folks ;-)

Aloha from Kaua%26#39;i!

While certainly all of our commercial lu%26#39;aus are just that - commercial lu%26#39;aus - the one that I consider the least ';touristy'; and most authentic (certainly the most Kaua%26#39;i-style IMO) is Smith%26#39;s -- they have been doing the lua%26#39;u for over 40 years at the same location - Smith%26#39;s Tropical Paradise - they are a long-time kama%26#39;aina family that truly has the ';aloha spirit'; and who share it with their guests.

My vote is for Smith%26#39;s.

Malama Pono,

Janet

If you have never done a luau I recommend it. Smith%26#39;s does the best one in my opinion. Princeville%26#39;s is terrible. Plastic blow up junk. I have not done any on the South Shore but a few threads have mentioned they enjoyed the Sheratons.

We loved Smith%26#39;s luau - enjoyed it so much the first time, we did it again last year when we were in Kauai again. I have been to one on Maui as well, but that felt like a slick Hollywood production compared to Smith%26#39;s. The Smith%26#39;s is down home . . . feels more like you are part of the family in some ways . . . and I enjoyed the gardens and imu ceremony as well as the dancing and food. :)

Lanai or Molokini Snorkel

Which is the best spot to snorkel? What is the difference between one %26amp; the other? I wish to take a snorkel cruise, but don%26#39;t know which is the best spot?

Thank you!

Lanai or Molokini Snorkel

We took the one that heads to Lanai, it was fabulous. First we paused off a bay and swam in more shallow waters, saw lots of fish and sea turtles. Then they took us around the island and we put in at a rocky cove for lunch and everybody nosed around the tidepools and saw eels. Next we headed out into deeper water and there was a large rock (not big enough to be an island - but eeryone was a bit hesitant to go in. Wow - there was a reef there and the fish were abundant and gorgeous. They had to practically drag everyone back into the boat.

The biggest choice is whether you want to go where the crowd will be. I haven%26#39;t done the Molokini tour, lots of people do, but we loved the one we did.

Don%26#39;t think either could be bad, just whatever you prefer.

Lanai or Molokini Snorkel

This is a question that is asked very frequently on this forum. Just do a search and you will find multiple threads on this. Here is one:

tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g29220-i86-k976442…

BTW, I would go for Lana%26#39;i.

I have been on the Molokini tour twice. Once ten years ago and once this last Sept.--there was a huge difference in the amount of fish--alot less the most recent time. I have gone snorkling recently around lanai, not with boat cruise but just in the bay--and I think it is more pristine, more fish etc. then anything around Maui. So I would agree with other two people, Do Lanai.

LesRose, what company did you take the tour with?

Hi guys, I think we are going to stay at Kaanapali Royal condo. We are not driving, so what is the best transport to get to the harbor for the Molokini and Lanai cruises?

Thanks!!!:)

I can%26#39;t remember the name of the company we went snoekeling with - they were in Lahaina and did not use catamaran. Small group and just great.

As for your most recent question - you can actually catch a bus from Whalers Village into Lahaina - it stops at several spots in town including very near the docks. My brain can%26#39;t get a grip on your location - but most of Kaanapali is close.